Wednesday, 18 January 2012

Aeneas' Flight From Troy




The object of my choice is a painting by an Italian artist, Federico Barocci. The painting is called Aeneas’ Flight from Troy. It is an oil painting about 62.5 by 101.5 inches in size and was commissioned during the Late Renaissance in 1598 (Richards 1961). It currently resides just 4 kilometres away from Rome’s city center in the Galleria Borghese. The first thing about this painting that caught my attention was the title, “Aeneas’ Flight from Troy”. I usually prefer religious art from this period as I believe it is quite beautiful, but since a religious theme is prominent in most pieces created at this time, a painting based on Virgil’s epic poem, The Aeneid, naturally sparked my interest. As mentioned, religious art during this period was highly prevalent throughout Europe. It is for this reason that I tend to forget that the Renaissance was a period that reflected on the art and myths of Classical Greece (in this case, a Roman poet) and shaped them to fit with the emerging ideas of humanism. Still, I find it interesting that Barocci would base his painting off of a Pagan poet while Christianity was so prominent.  Having read and enjoyed The Aeneid, I was already interested in how Barocci would present Aeneas fleeing from Troy and how he would give the piece a distinct Renaissance feel while preserving the integrity of the poem.  







                         Wikipedia 






                                           





Works Cited
Richards, Louise S. "A Study for Aeneas' Flight from Troy." The Bulletin of the Cleveland Museum of Art (Cleveland Museum of Art) 48 (1961): 63-65.


Tuesday, 17 January 2012

Visual Properties of Aeneas' Flight


            Upon first glance, Barocci successfully manages to capture the attention of viewers through Aeneas, the central figure in the painting. The moment Barocci chooses to paint is when Aeneas must carry his elderly father, Anchises, on his back out of the burning city of Troy. This is an odd position for a figure in Renaissance painting, as it shows Anchises in a state of weakness and dependence on another, whereas typically in Renaissance art the focus is upon the strength and beauty of humanity due to the humanistic ideals of the time. This therefore brings attention to the scene. Also shown in this painting are Aeneas’ son, Ascanius, and wife, Creusa. There is some distance between Creusa and her family in this painting, perhaps alluding to her separation and eventual death during their flight from Troy. Interestingly, Anchises is painted clutching a gold figurine of Athena, the goddess of courage, wisdom, and warfare. Next to Athena is Poseidon, god of the sea. In the Homeric poems, the Odyssey and the Illiad, Athena aids the Greeks in their battle against the Trojans while Poseidon is an ally of Aeneas. The use of colour and light gives the painting a more dramatic appearance. The city looks very dark with only the flames giving light to the city. While both Ascanius and Creusa are painting wearing red garments, Aeneas is wearing a rich green garment. This use of green adds to Aeneas’ heroic qualities and symbolizes new life, courage and growth, all of which are presented in The Aeneid. The figures in contrast to the dark cityscape are very pale. The darkness almost looms around Aeneas and his family, showing their fragility and mortality amongst and the death and destruction that surrounds them. In the background, Greek soldiers can be seen massacring Trojans in fine detail. For instance, one can make out a soldier being thrown from a balcony.  The architecture in this painting reflects the Renaissance ideas of the Classical era, as well as their desire to imitate and pay homage to it. However, as is typical of the Renaissance period, artists impose aspects of their own period upon that of an ancient time. An instance of this is seen in the banister and staircase on the left hand side of the painting. They look like they belong in a 16th century manor, rather than the ancient city of Troy. The building in the background also appears to have architectural features that were prevalent in the Renaissance. The dome looks similar to that of Brunelleschi’s dome in 15th century Florence. At the bottom left corner, at the base of the banister, is Barocci’s signature along with what can be presumed as the date at which he completed the painting. Barocci’s painting is one that deserves deeper consideration. Upon further inspection, one can see the great detail Barocci put into this painting and his mastery of his craft.

Related Images

 Raphael's Aeneas
Here Raphael is using the same scene from the poem with a completely different approach. This highlights the Renaissance's focus on the classical era.



Venus Presenting Arms to Aeneas
While taken from a different scene, this painting by Nicolas Poussin shows the desire to portray the classical era, even in France during the Renaissance.
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/c8/Nicolas_Poussin_-_Venus_Presenting_Arms_to_Aeneas_-_WGA18308.jpg


Dido and Aeneas
This painting, by Rutilio Manetti, is yet another depiction of Aeneas, this time interacting with Dido. It is a perfect example of how Renaissance artists took Classicism and shaped it to their own era. 
http://www.terminartors.com/files/artworks/4/6/0/46076/Manetti_Rutilio-Dido_and_Aeneas.normal.jpg

Saturday, 14 January 2012

Revised Visual Analysis 2


            Barocci makes use of many straight lines consistently throughout the painting. A few circular shapes are used in the painting; however, straight lines dominate most of the piece. If one were to make a diagram of the painting, most likely the following details would be included: A general outline of the central figures, the unique building in the distance, and the entryway through which the figures are running. I would exclude the banister and staircase, the soldiers fighting in the background, and the rubble in the bottom right corner because these are portions of the painting that are not necessary to its overall integrity.
            It is easy to see that Barocci uses a lot of contrast in this painting. Dark shades are mostly used, especially in the background. Two other prominent colours used in the garments and battle scene are red and green. Overall, the painting itself is highly saturated. When used with the contrast in the painting, the colours add to the realism and place an emphasis on the danger that Aeneas and his family are trying to flee from.
            Upon first glance, the viewer is drawn to the central figures, Aeneas and his family. The rich red and green used in their garments catch the attention of the viewer, as well as their pale skin colour which contrasts with the dark, burning city of Troy. By using this contrast, the artist is able to successfully make Aeneas and his family the focal point of the piece.
            The central figures of Barocci’s painting are from Virgil’s epic poem, the Aeneid. The main character in the Aeneid is Aeneas, shown just off center, carrying his elderly father, Anchises, over his shoulder. To the right of Aeneas is his wife, Creusa, who is slightly separated from her family. This almost foreshadows her disappearance and death shortly after this scene in the Aeneid. Finally, on the left of Aeneas, is his son, Ascanius. In this particular scene, Barocci choses to show the family fleeing from Troy after the city fell to the Greeks. Barocci is able to effectively express the emotion in the family’s faces. The viewer can clearly see the distress on Ascanius and Creusa’s face. On Aeneas’ face, Barocci manages to capture a more reserved, calm emotion. It is Anchises’ face that really stands out, however, showing uncertainty and a greater fear than what we can see in the rest of the family’s expressions. The environment that Barocci has created is grand, showing the magnificence that was the city of Troy. It is also dark, showing the time when Aeneas and his family fled, and dangerous. This is shown by the flames slowly engulfing the city, and the soldiers at war in the background.
            During my research, I came across many instances where an emphasis was placed on the patronage of the piece. The piece was originally commissioned by Emperor Rudolph II in 1586 and while Barocci was known for his religious pieces, the Emperor did not prefer devotional images (Richards). That being said, the central argument for my paper will focus on the Classicism of the piece, the figures, and the architecture.


Bibliography



Bertela, Giovana Gaeta. Disegni di Federico Barocci. Citta di Castello: Leo S. Olschki, 1975. Print.
"Classicism." The Columbia Encyclopedia, 6th ed.. 2008. Encyclopedia.com. 23 Feb 2012
Friedlaender, Walter. "Federico Barocci." The Burlington Magazine (1964): 186-187. <http://www.jstor.org/stable/874281>.
Gillgren, Peter. Siting Federico Barocci and the Renaissance Aesthetic. Ashgate Publishing, 2011.
Index, Myth. Aeneas. 2007. Electronic. 22 02 2012. <http://www.mythindex.com/greek-mythology/A/Aeneas.html>.
Lingo, Stuart. Federico Barocci. London: Yale University Press, 2008. Print.
Paul, Carole. The Borghese Collections and the Display of Art in the Age of the Grand Tour. Aldershot: Ashgate Publishing, 2008. Print.
Richards, Louise S. "A Study for Aeneas' Flight from Troy." The Bulletin of the Cleveland Museum of Art (1961): 63-65. <http://www.jstor.org/stable/25142447>.



Thursday, 12 January 2012

A New Reflection



            I found that even after only a bit of research, my interest in the painting has increased. I particularly enjoy reading about Barocci’s influence for the building in the background of the painting. I was already familiar with the story of Aeneas and his family, so having that knowledge allowed me to focus on smaller aspects of the painting that one would not catch upon first glance. For instance, the small figurine that Anchises carries with him, or the soldiers at war in the background of the painting. The revised visual analysis made me look at parts of the painting that I hadn’t considered before like the environment, shapes, and colours used in the painting.  
            I originally chose this painting because of the artist and the subject matter. The artist, Federico Barocci, was from a town in Italy called Urbino in the region of Marche. I was interested in a painter from Urbino because I had been given the opportunity to study in Urbino last summer. Spending a month there, I learned quite a bit about the history and art. Since I enjoy studying Classicism, I was of course drawn to the theme of the painting. After thoroughly analysing the painting, I am drawn to it for a number of other reasons. I found the placement of the figures interesting, particularly the slight separation of Creusa. Also interesting is the architecture in the piece. It is not necessarily something that one would find in ancient Troy, rather Classical architecture with the Renaissance take on it. 

Saturday, 7 January 2012

Exam Prep

A list of 5 significant course themes:

1. Portrayal of religious figures and themes

2. Mythology in art

3. Marriage and instruction for brides in art 

4. Northern Renaissance art

5. Renaissance guilds and patrons


3 mock exam questions:

1. Discuss the importance of showing acceptable behaviour for woman, brides in particular, in Renaissance art and why. 

2. Discuss key differences between northern Renaissance art and Italian Renaissance art.

3. Discuss the significance of guilds and patrons during the Renaissance. 

Friday, 6 January 2012

Mock Syllabus on Aeneas' Flight from Troy


Part 1 - From Virgil to Barocci

In part one, the epic poem which inspired Barocci will be briefly discussed to give background information on the theme of the painting.

     Key Questions
          Who is shown in the painting?
          What is its importance in Italian culture?
                                             in Renaissance art?
          How is this theme different from other Renaissance works of art in the way of Classicism?

       

     Readings
           Paul, The Borghese Collections, pg 91-2
       

Part 2 - Patronage and History of the Piece

The main focus of part two will discuss the historical background of the piece, why the piece was made and who it was commissioned for.

     Key Questions
          When was the piece created?
          Why was the theme chosen
          Where is the piece located today?
          Who was the piece created for?
          Was the piece handed down? Were others created?

     Readings
          Richards, "A Study for Aeneas' Flight from Troy", pg. 63-5
          Paul, The Borghese Collections and the Display of Art in the Age of the Grand Tour, pg. 1-5

Part 3 - Barocci's Use of Colour and its Effect

Part three will focus on the colour used in the painting and how it effects such things as the environment, the mood and the way we view the painting.

     Key Questions
          How does the colour set the atmosphere of the painting?
          How does the contrast effect the way we view the central figures to the rest of the painting?
          What do certain colours represent?

      Readings
          Lingo, Federico Barocci, pg. 201-4, 189-192    

Part 4 - The Renaissance Take on Classical Architecture

The fourth and final part will discuss the architecture shown in the painting.

     Key Questions
          What style was used?
          What inspired the structure in the background?
          Where can we see the Renaissance view on Classical architecture?

     Readings
          Lingo, Federico Barocci, pg.179-180, 185-6



*For full bibliography see the Revised Visual Analysis

Wednesday, 4 January 2012

Revised Thesis

The paper will discuss the matter of the Renaissance idea of Classicism and how it comes through in Barocci's painting. Another focus of the paper involves the figures in the painting. This includes where they are placed, how they are reacting to the scene, their garments and expressions, and how they add to the painting. Finally, the architecture seen in the piece will be discussed, addressing Barocci's inspiration for the architecture.